Clawback Clause Explained: When You May Have to Repay a Bonus or Commission
This page is general information, not legal advice.
A clawback clause lets an employer or client take back money it has already paid you. It most often shows up with signing bonuses, retention bonuses, relocation payments and sales commissions, and it can also appear in severance and equity agreements. The idea sounds fair at first: if you leave right away or a deal falls through, the money comes back. The trouble is in the details. Who decides the trigger, how long it lasts, how much you repay and how the company collects it can turn a reward into a debt. This page covers six common clawback problems. For each one you get an illustrative example, why it matters, and wording you can propose. Whether a clawback can be enforced, and how, varies a lot by jurisdiction.
The example clauses below are illustrative. They are not taken from any real company's agreement.
1. Full repayment if you leave, with no proration
A typical clause might read: "If Employee's employment ends for any reason within twenty-four (24) months of the Start Date, Employee shall repay the full Signing Bonus."
Why it works against you
"For any reason" can include being laid off, or resigning because the role changed. Full repayment means that leaving one day before the deadline costs as much as leaving in your first week. If you're comparing offers, see offer letter red flags.
What to ask for instead
Sample wording to propose: "Repayment applies only if Employee resigns without good reason or is terminated for cause. The amount repayable is reduced pro rata for each full month of employment completed."
2. Commission chargebacks that follow you after you leave
A typical clause might read: "Commissions are advances against future earnings. If a customer cancels, fails to pay or receives a refund at any time, the related commission shall be repaid by the Salesperson."
Why it works against you
Calling commissions "advances" means none of your pay is truly earned. "At any time" puts no end date on the risk, so a customer cancelling long after you've left can still create a bill. You also have no control over refunds, discounts or how the company handles the account once you're gone.
What to ask for instead
Sample wording to propose: "A commission is earned when the customer pays the invoice. Chargebacks apply only to cancellations within 90 days of payment, and do not apply after the Salesperson's employment ends or to refunds granted at Company's discretion."
3. The company alone decides the trigger
A typical clause might read: "Company may recover any bonus or incentive paid if Company determines, in its sole discretion, that Employee engaged in misconduct or failed to meet Company standards."
Why it works against you
"Sole discretion" and vague phrases like "Company standards" let the company decide on its own that you owe money, with no process and no chance to respond. That can be used as leverage in an exit negotiation or a dispute. See liquidated damages clauses explained for a related kind of payment penalty.
What to ask for instead
Sample wording to propose: "Recovery applies only after a finding of gross misconduct that directly affected the amount paid. Employee will receive written notice of the reasons and a reasonable opportunity to respond before any recovery."
4. Deducting the repayment from your final paycheck
A typical clause might read: "Employee authorizes Company to deduct any amount owed under this Agreement from wages, accrued vacation pay, expense reimbursements or any other sums due to Employee."
Why it works against you
This lets the company collect first and argue later. Your final pay could shrink or disappear right when you need it. Many places restrict what employers can deduct from wages, but the rules vary by jurisdiction. Don't assume a clause like this is valid just because you signed it.
What to ask for instead
Sample wording to propose: "Any repayment will be agreed in writing after employment ends and paid under a reasonable repayment schedule. Company will not deduct any amount from wages or other sums due except as permitted by law and with Employee's separate written consent."
5. Repaying the gross amount you never received
A typical clause might read: "Employee shall repay the gross amount of the bonus, without reduction for taxes or other withholdings, within thirty (30) days of the repayment event."
Why it works against you
You received the bonus after tax, but the clause asks for the pre-tax amount back. Whether and how you can recover the tax already withheld depends on where you live and the timing. A short deadline on top of that can leave you finding a large sum quickly.
What to ask for instead
Sample wording to propose: "Employee will repay the net amount actually received after taxes and withholdings. Repayment may be made in equal monthly installments over a period agreed between the parties."
6. No time limit on the clawback
A typical clause might read: "Company's right to recover incentive compensation under this Section shall survive termination of this Agreement indefinitely."
Why it works against you
An open-ended right means a payment is never really yours. Years later, a former employer could reopen old bonuses. Survival language like this is worth checking anywhere it appears. See confidentiality survival clauses explained for how open-ended survival works in other clauses.
What to ask for instead
Sample wording to propose: "Company's right to recover any payment under this Section expires 12 months after the payment date, or on the date employment ends if earlier, except for recovery required by law."
Also worth a look
Clawbacks often sit alongside other exit terms. Check whether disputes over repayment go to private arbitration (see mandatory arbitration clauses explained) and whether a severance payment can be taken back for an alleged breach (see severance agreement red flags). Some agreements link repayment to breaking a restriction on future work, so read non-compete clauses explained too. Freelancers and sales contractors should also review contractor payment terms red flags.
Scan your own contract free
Clawback language is often buried in a bonus letter, commission plan or policy that the contract refers to. Upload your offer letter, employment contract or commission plan to the ScanMyTerms employment contract review as a PDF, DOCX, TXT or MD file, or just photograph it. In about a minute it flags clauses that work against you, with the risk level, exact wording, why it hurts and how to change it. The free preview needs no sign-up and shows the risk count and the first two findings. The full report is $5. ScanMyTerms does not use your documents to train AI models, and reports are deleted after 7 days.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Rules on bonus repayment, commission chargebacks and wage deductions vary by jurisdiction, so for decisions about a specific agreement, talk to a qualified employment lawyer where you live.
Sources
- All clause examples on this page are illustrative and written for this guide. They are not quoted from any real company's agreement.
Check your clawback clause with a free preview, no sign-up needed →